NewsLocal NewsInvestigationsFertility Clinic Failure


2 families whose embryos are no longer viable file lawsuits against UH: 'It's a tremendous loss'

Couples told their stored embryos no longer viable
Posted at 9:53 PM, Mar 11, 2018
and last updated 2019-03-28 16:01:58-04

Two class action lawsuit has been filed against University Hospitals following a refrigerator malfunction that has left the viability of 2,000 eggs and embryos in question.

On Monday, a lawsuit was filed by the Peiffer Rosca Wolf Abdullah Carr & Kane law firm in the names of a Pennsylvania couple on behalf of the estimated 700 patients affected by University Hospital's fertility clinic malfunction.

In a formal declaration of the class action lawsuit, Lydia Floyd, a representative of the firm, said the Pennsylvania couple filing the suit called the hospital on Monday, March 5 to set up an appointment to begin the implantation procedure using frozen embryos stored in the clinic's storage bank.

Later that evening, the couple, who has been trying to have children through this in vitro fertilization (IVF) process for eight years, received the heartbreaking news that their embryos had been destroyed by a temperature fluctuation.

"Those embryos represented their hopes, their promise of having children and a family," Floyd said.

Floyd said the lawsuit seeks to hold University Hospitals and other defendants in this case responsible.

"There is the loss of having a child here, and the pain and tie and expense that many of these victims already had invested in their fertility journey," Floyd said.

The Pennsylvania couple filing the suit had already been subjected to an invasive and technical IVF process, which includes surgical procedures and an intense drug regiment. They are also now much older than when they started this process, and the chances of them producing viable and strong eggs in order to become pregnant have decreased, lessening their chances of having a child.

A lawsuit was also filed on Sunday by attorney Robert DiCello of DiCello, Levitt & Casey on behalf of Amber and Elliott Ash, a local couple who had two embryos stored with UH. 

The couple received notification of the failure on Friday and over the weekend, were told by physicians that their embryos are no longer viable. 

“It’s heartbreaking. Just heartbreaking,” Amber Ash said. “The medical community calls it tissue, I like to think of it as my children. My frozen children.”

The Ash family welcomed Ethan, now 2-years-old, into their lives through in-vitro fertilization, or IVF, at UH. 

Elliott was diagnosed with a rare cancer in 2003, and at age 23, decided to bank his sperm before they were destroyed by chemotherapy. The couple have had their embryos stored at UH since 2014, paying about $400 a year for the service. 

They had hoped to give Ethan a genetic sibling.

“You put so much faith into the physicians and the medical team, and like I said, to have this taken away — your hopes and dreams destroyed. It’s a tremendous loss,” Amber said. 

The hope and ultimate goal with the lawsuit, the family said, is to make sure another family doesn’t feel the same loss ever again.

“I find it very hard to believe that in this day and age, there are not better safeguard and practices that could be put in place,” Amber added. 

DiCello said he is in talks with other patients to add them to the class-action complaint.

“I just urge everyone, before you judge what they’ve gone through, or what they’re going through, or what their motives for doing it, ask yourselves, ‘What would it be like if I had my family’s treasure lost by a hospital that just didn’t care enough to check on it?’” DiCello said. 

The Ash family said they still have many unanswered questions regarding the failure, even after speaking with two physicians. UH has not clarified if it was a mechanical or human error at this point. The malfunction occurred sometime between the overnight hours of Saturday, March 3 and Sunday, March 4.

“What is most disturbing to me is that everyone I talked to has been informed by UH that their embryos are not viable, they’ve been destroyed, different from what has been out there publicly which has been that they’ve been compromised, we don’t know. I think this problem is far more serious than has been presented so far,” said Team LGM attorney Tom Merriman.

“Our intent is to file a lawsuit on behalf of a large group of women and couples who have lost their embryos. We intend to do that within the next couple of days, “ he said.

In a statement regarding the lawsuits, UH officials told News 5 the following: 

We understand why some people might feel compelled to take this step. Any lawsuits being filed will have no bearing on the independent review being conducted or our determination to help patients who have suffered this loss

Read the entire lawsuit against University Hospitals below: 

Class-Action Lawsuit Filed Against University Hospitals

Download our streaming app on your favorite device.  Click here for more.

Click here to see how we’re following through on impactful stories from your community.

5 On Your Side Investigators Contact Form
Do you have an issue or story that you want 5 On Your Side Investigators to look into? Email or fill out the form below.