NewsLocal NewsInvestigationsDiagnosis: Debt


Daughter fights back after her father was denied life-saving brain surgery

Posted at 7:51 AM, Oct 07, 2019

CLEVELAND — Chuck and Angie Graham have been married 33 years.

They have been through a lot together in that time, but perhaps their biggest challenge yet came in January.

The Diagnosis

"I woke up in the morning to go to work and I lost my balance a couple times and fell down," said Chuck.

Angie said she heard something and yelled up to him if he was okay.

"He said he was falling and couldn't walk," Angie recalled tearing up.

An ambulance ride, and several tests and scans later, the Grahams had their answer -- and it was devastating.

"She said that I had a very aggressive tumor in my brain and it was malignant," said Chuck.

Such a diagnosis can make you feel so helpless, said Angie.

The Denial

They say the next blow was just as unexpected.

Their health insurance provider denied covering the procedure Chuck's neurosurgeon recommended to treat his cancerous brain tumor; saying it was "experimental" and "investigational".

The laser ablation procedure was FDA-cleared a decade ago, but that does not guarantee coverage.

The Grahams appealed the decision. Chuck was prepped for surgery hoping for a last-minute approval, that never came, and he was sent home.

"Just the look on his face, broke my heart," she remembered.

"He's a veteran. He's a dad. He's a husband, a grandpa and a friend who would do anything for you. How could they not value him?"

Fighting Back

Chuck's family took action.

His daughter Jen Koons led the charge.

"They've just always been there for us," said Jen.

And now she wanted to be there for them.

Jen turned to the power of social media.

She had previously sent the letter to the company before posting it to Facebook.

It began: "An open letter to SummaCare and our health insurance industry..."

Jen wrote about her father's fight with brain cancer and health insurance.

The letter continued: "I hope thousands of people read this letter and understand that our physicians do not get to decide what's best for us, insurance companies do."

Her post was shared nearly 3,000 times. Hundreds commented. Her message resonated.

Fighting Back

"I would say don't give up," said Jen.

She learned about the right to an external review. It is a free service all health plan issuers must provide once the internal appeals process has been exhausted.

An independent organization reviewed Chuck's case and overturned the denial.

Two weeks after he had been sent home from the hospital, Chuck got the surgery his doctor had recommended.

"I just think we would've had a whole different scenario today if he hadn't had that surgery," said Angie.

The external reviewer found Chuck's procedure "medically necessary" and "beneficial" for his condition.

"I just want people to understand their rights and to find their voice," said Jen.

Chuck's tumor is shrinking, and Jen is happy for how things turned out for her dad, but angry, she says, for the people who don't have someone to advocate for them.

"There's how many people who go home and think, 'Oh, this is just the way it is.'"

In her open letter, she wrote: People deserve better. People deserve to count on their health insurance. They are more than a premium payment.

Chuck's provider called the procedure "experimental and investigational". It was FDA-cleared a decade ago, but that does not guarantee coverage.

There are not clear guidelines as to what defines "experimental and investigational".

It can create a gray area where often, patients seeking innovative uses for a procedure are caught up.

"I'd like to see legislation around experimental procedures," said Tracy H. Porter, Cleveland State University.

She said she'd like to see clarification and rules put in place like with pre-existing conditions.

"I would also like to see something where we're educating patients more on their rights."

That is why Chuck and his family said they wanted to share their story. To help others navigate the often-murky waters of a diagnosis and a denial.

Jen has kept meticulous track of her father's paperwork. She has two, bulky binders filled with research, correspondence with doctors, the hospital, insurance, and notes from outside agencies.

"I would say don't give up," she said.

News 5 did reach out to SummaCare for this story.

They provided us with this statement:

"First and foremost, at SummaCare, we want what is best for our members in all cases. In accordance with federal privacy laws, we cannot discuss the specific medical care or associated claims of any of our members."


The Ohio Department of Insurance is a helpful resource if you have questions about a health insurance issue.

"If you have a question, don't try to figure it out yourself, we can help navigate that," said Jana Jarrett, assistant director of the consumer services division at the Ohio Department of Insurance. "If we can't help you, we will definitely point you in the right direction."

For consumer questions call: 800-686-1526

For questions about independent reviews: 614-644-0188

They also have online resources where you can file a complaint or ask a question online.

According to the agency, 572 cases were submitted last year for external review. Denials were reversed in 33% of the cases.

Jen said she also found helpful resources through the Patient Advocate Foundation.

Diagnosis: Debt Viewer Contact Form
Do you have a story of medical debt you would like to share with News 5 investigators? Email or fill out the form below.