NewsLocal NewsInvestigationsFertility Clinic Failure

Actions

Court rules that embryos are not people

Court sides with University Hospitals in lawsuit
Posted: 8:44 PM, May 02, 2019
Updated: 2019-05-03 06:42:22-04
University Hospital.jpeg

CLEVELAND — An Ohio appellate court ruled against a couple that believe their frozen embryos lost in a hospital freezer malfunction should have been treated as people, not property.

Last month, Wendy Penniman’s case against University Hospitals went before the 8th District Court of Appeals. The couple is among 950 families who were impacted when a storage tank malfunction at University Hospitals destroyed 4,000 eggs and embryos in 2018. The Penniman family lost three embryos.

A three-judge panel heard oral arguments in the case where the Penniman family and their attorney Bruce Taubman asked that frozen embryos be considered living persons. Each side had 15 minutes to argue their case. It was a case of first impressions.

Attorneys for University Hospitals argued that Ohio law does not see embryos as human beings and doing so would lead down a problematic path.

If the court had ruled in Penniman's favor, it could have set a precedent around the country to determine when life begins.

RELATED: Judges to decide if frozen embryos are living persons as case goes before Court of Appeals

CLICK TO SEE THE MOST ORIGINAL REPORTING IN NORTHEAST OHIO

News 5 Investigates Contact Form
Do you have an issue or story that you want the News 5 Investigates team to look into? Email InvestigatorTips@wews.com or fill out the form below.