NewsLocal NewsInvestigations


Sophisticated scam that hit Hinckley seniors has twist ending, and should serve as a warning to all

Hinckley senior citizens hit with scam ending with a twist but still is a warning.
Posted at 5:00 AM, Jan 13, 2020
and last updated 2020-01-13 18:18:31-05

HINCKLEY, OH — Grandparent scams are targeting people right now in our area. Senior citizens get phone calls saying their grandchildren are in trouble and need money. In Hinckley, there’s an interesting twist to all of this, but still a big warning for you.

"These people are sophisticated,” said Timothy Simko, 72, from Hinckley. On January 2, 2020 he thought his grandson was on the line. The caller even said it was "Little Andy."

"I was convinced. No reason to doubt,” said Simko. “We're the only ones who call him Little Andy.”

The supposed grandson said he totaled his Dodge Durango, a car, in fact, he owned at one time. The crooks did their research. "How did they find out when that truck was sold two years ago that he had a Durango?” Simpko questioned.

Simko was told to get $3,000 cash and send it FedEx. He did that. However, right after he got home from the store, something just wasn’t right.

“All of a sudden, like the good Lord hit me in the head," Simko said. "How do I know that was Andy?"

He ran to the Hinckley Police Department. Sgt. Mike Schroll helped him stop the package just in time. "These scammers are able to convince these people to overnight the package,” said Sgt. Schroll. “So, you're talking a couple of hours before these things are picked up and getting on a plane."

The $3,000 was saved, but scammers weren't done calling senior citizens in Hinckley. Just five days later, they were asking for even more money.

"She needed $9,000 to get out of jail,” said Fred Haddix, 82, who helped raise his granddaughter. He got a phone call tha was supposedly from her. She even called him "Papa," her special name for him. "That feeling at first…you don't think real quick sometimes,” said Haddix.

He got the cash out of his savings account and went to UPS. But just a little later, he talked with his granddaughter. "She came over she said, ‘No, nothing wrong with me. I'm not hurt or anything.’"

He dashed to UPS and caught it before it left. "I says 'I got scammed,' but I says [to the store clerk], 'Lucky for me that you still had it there,'” said Haddix.

Hinckley Police helped in that case, too. Sgt. Schroll said when detectives hear about money already on its way, that’s a bad feeling. “95% or more of the's too late," he said.

So, two lucky guys in the end, and one big message for you.

"Contact that family member [who’s supposedly calling you] on their actual phone number. Reach out to another family member to just verify,” said Sgt. Schroll.

"These [scammers] are good. They do their homework,” warned Simko.

“There's a lot of older people that it happens to every day. As we speak, it's going on,” said Haddix.

Police said it's extremely important to warn grandparents and all seniors about this scam. Crooks are digging to find details about your family. Whether it’s through social media or other online info, keep your accounts safe and be careful what you share.

Download our streaming app on your favorite device.  Click here for more.

Click here to see how we’re following through on impactful stories from your community.

5 On Your Side Investigators Contact Form
Do you have an issue or story that you want 5 On Your Side Investigators to look into? Email or fill out the form below.