NewsLocal NewsInvestigations


Updated NAACP-LDF report concludes lawsuits 'may be viable' over CLE water billing policies

NAACP-LDF says CLE water response 'misleading and incorrect'
Posted at 6:09 PM, Jun 10, 2019
and last updated 2019-12-10 12:00:31-05

CLEVELAND — The NAACP Legal Defense Fund issued its final, updated report Monday into what it calls "discriminatory" billing practices used by the Cleveland Division of Water.

The 104-page report follows a preliminary report issued in May that found the policies and practices utilized by the Cleveland Division of Water contributes to a "devastating" loss of home ownership and unfairly impacts people of color.

In this updated report, researchers combed through years of water tax liens and census data to document the disparate impact water department policies are having in black communities in Cleveland.

For example, it found 66-69% of water liens were placed in majority-black census tracks in 2017-2018, while only 18-22% were placed in majority-white tracts.

NAACP LDF Clevleand Water Lein Data

The final report concludes that "litigation may be viable and appropriate" to address practices that "disproportionately impact Black communities."

In another example, the report found Water Review Board hearings to allow customers to dispute bills "are rarely held."

Water board hearings graphic
Cleveland Water Board Hearings

"We have to stop the harm here," said Sparky Abraham, Senior Justice Fellow with the NAACP Legal Defense Fund.

In a separate development, the NAACP-LDF says a letterit sent to City Cleveland City council seeking a meeting to discuss its finding has gone unanswered.

"I would much prefer that Cleveland Water change its practices but I think that there should be a worry there that they may actually be violating a law and they might be held liable for it," said Abraham.

Sparky Abraham and Ron
Sparky Abraham with NAACP LDF is interviewed by Ron Regan

The report outlines a number of possible legal issues including:

  • Denying due process
  • Intentional discrimination claims
  • Violations of Title VI requiring federal funds be dispersed without discrimination
  • FHA housing discrimination violations
  • Unfair & Deceptive business practices

So far, the the City of Cleveland has issued only a single news release denying the allegations and which the NAACP-LDF says it both "incorrect and misleading."

The final report also credits the News 5 Investigative Team as being "instrumental in uncovering a series of issues" with the water department in recent years.

"The stories that you elicited from residents were extremely helpful," said Abraham, "and just the reporting you did really did a deep dive into the process."

Download our streaming app on your favorite device.  Click here for more.

Click here to see how we follow through

5 On Your Side Investigators Contact Form
Do you have an issue or story that you want 5 On Your Side Investigators to look into? Email or fill out the form below.