Gov. John Kasich has been repeating an odd talking point lately: He keeps saying how unpopular he was as governor.
The Ohio leader and presidential candidate said it in a Republican debate on March 30. On April 24, he repeated it on CBS Face the Nation when host John Dickerson asked if he thought it was possible for a candidate to change negative perceptions about him.
“After my first year as governor, I was one of the most unpopular governors, maybe the most unpopular governor in the country,” Kasich said. “It takes a long time to change negatives. People have to see that you're actually being fruitful in your work. What happened with me is when people started getting work, and we started balancing budgets and reaching out to people, it changed.”
Is he right about being the least beloved state leader across the land after his first year in office?
An August 2011 poll by Public Policy Polling said that with a 36 percent approval rating, he was the second or third least popular governor in the country.
That was at least a few points better than in March 2011, when the same pollsters found Kasich’s approval ratings in the basement at 30 percent, and in May 2011 at 33 percent.
Where was the love?
In April 2011, his third month in office, Kasich made boatloads of enemies with a stroke of his pen. Kasich signed a massive union reform bill that prohibited forced union membership for state employees, mandated merit pay, outlawed strikes and limited collective bargaining rights for public employees. Unlike a similar reform bill in Wisconsin, Ohio’s SB 5 included police and firefighters. The political backlash was immediate, and a repeal effort quickly coalesced and reversedKasich’s attempt at reform.
Vying for the, uh, honor of most unpopular governor in 2011 was Florida’s Republican Gov. Rick Scott. Public Policy Polling found that Kasich edged out Scott for most unfavorable governor in September 2011 with a 53 percent disapproval rating, compared to Scott’s 52 percent.
But Kasich said he was (maybe) the country’s most unpopular governor after his first year. If he took office in January 2011, then we’d need to know his approval rating for the first few months of 2012.
PolitiFact’s Louis Jacobson looked at the cast of rookie governors in February 2012, one year into their terms, for Governing magazine. Kasich made Jacobson’s list of the seven rookie governors who were struggling the most. Here they are, by approval rating:
Jerry Brown (D-CA): 47 percent
Rick Scott (R-FL): 43 percent
Neil Abercrombie (D-HI): 39 percent
Scott Walker (R-WI): 38 percent
Nikki Haley (R-SC): 35 percent
John Kasich (R-OH): 33 percent
Lincoln Chafee (I -RI): 22 percent
Based on these numbers, Kasich is the second-most unpopular governor after his first year. But Jacobson’s analysis only counted the 26 governors who took office at the start of 2011.
Jacobson notes that approval ratings for governors aren’t exactly the holy grail of polling. He had to consult a handful of different polling groups for his comparison.
Peter A. Brown, the assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Poll, concurred. “Nobody’s done every governor in the country,” he said. “There’s no reason to.” He said Quinnipiac only polls from nine states.
“What you can say is that it’s not possible to determine (whether Kasich was the least popular governor in the country),” Brown said. “But in a general sense, he’s probably right. He was certainly close to the bottom.”
Rob Nichols, Kasich’s presidential campaign spokesman who was also the spokesman for the governor’s office in 2011, told us, “Well yeah, we had just come from the election with $10 million in negative attack ads against us. So the last thing you saw was all this TV, trashing him.”
Nichols also gave us this anecdote: In August 2011, his official email inbox was bombarded with form letters that started out, “Dear Gov. Kasich staff member, I wanted Gov. Kasich to know that I voted for him in the Worst Governor Ever contest at www.worstgovernorever.com....”
“I got so many that I had to get our IT people to route them to a special mailbox so they wouldn’t destroy my inbox,” Nichols said.
Ohioans started to warm to Kasich after the turbulent first year. Later in 2012, his rating bumped up to the 40s, and was up to 53 percent approval in 2013. Quinnipiac University had Kasich polling at 62 percent favorability in October 2015.
Our ruling
Kasich said, "After my first year as governor, I was one of the most unpopular governors, maybe the most unpopular governor in the country."
At its lowest, in March 2011, his favorability among the Ohioans who had just elected him was an abysmal 30 percent. That was bad enough to crown Kasich as the least-popular governor in America for a brief period.
We rate this claim True.
Sources
Poll, Public Policy Polling, Aug. 18, 2011
Poll, Public Policy Polling, Sept. 30, 2011
Poll, Brown University, Oct. 10, 2012
Interview, Peter A. Brown, assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Poll, April 28, 2016
Interview, Rob Nichols, spokesman, John Kasich for America, April 28, 2016
Email interview, Louis Jacobson, senior correspondent at PolitiFact, Apr. 27, 2016
Article, “Rookie Governors: Who’s Struggling?” Governing, Feb. 23, 2012
Article, “Ohio governor signs anti-union bill,” Reuters, Apr. 1, 2011
Article, “Who’s the most unpopular governor in America?” Mother Jones, May 31, 2011
Article, “John Kasich’s remarkable rebound continues in Ohio,” Washington Post, Feb. 29, 2013
Article, “John Kasich replaces Rick Scott as most unpopular governor in 2011,” Huffington Post, Sept. 30, 2011
Article, “Ohio turns back a law limiting unions’ rights,” New York Times,Nov. 8, 2011
Article, “How mean old John Kasich became Mr. Nice,” Politico Magazine, Feb. 3, 2016
