WEWS - Cleveland, Ohio
1 weather alerts 1 closings/delays
Watch Now
Watch Now
1 weather alerts 1 closings/delays
WEWS - Cleveland, Ohio
Watch Now
Watch Now
Close ×
Live Watch
Alerts
  • Stream News 5
    • Where You Can Watch Streaming
    • Replay: News 5 at 6
    • News 5 Livestream
  • Videos
    • Replay: News 5 at 6
    • News 5 livestream event
  • Weather
    • Hourly Forecast
    • Daily Forecast
    • Live Radar
    • Winter Weather Awareness
    • School Closings
    • Severe Weather Alerts
    • Weather News
    • Live Cameras
    • Power Outages
    • Tornado Safety
  • Academic Challenge
  • Pet Of The Week
  • News
    • Local
    • Cleveland Metro
    • Akron Canton
    • Ohio
    • National
    • World News
    • Schools
    • Two Americas
    • Missing Persons
    • Made Us Smile
    • Your Service
    • NASA Glenn
  • News by County
    • Cuyahoga County
    • Stark County News
    • Summit County
    • Lake County
    • Lorain County
    • Medina County News
    • Geauga County News
    • Portage County News
    • Ashtabula County News
    • Wayne County News
    • Ashland County News
    • Erie County News
    • Richland County News
    • Holmes County News
    • Huron County News
    • Tuscarawas County News
    • Carroll County News
  • Sports
    • Browns
    • Cavaliers
    • Guardians
    • Ohio State
    • Next Man Up
    • Browns Player of the Game
    • Student Athlete of the Week
  • Investigations
    • All Investigations
    • Breaking Their Silence
    • Dangerously Understaffed
    • County Jail
    • Fertility Clinic Failure
    • Cleveland Water
    • Diagnosis: Debt
    • Social Insecurity
    • Domestic Violence
  • Don't Waste Your Money Team
  • We Follow Through
  • Let's Go NEO
  • Politics
    • 2025 Primary Election Results
    • Abortion in Ohio
    • Marijuana in Ohio
    • Local Politics
    • Elections Local
    • Ohio Politics
    • National Politics
    • Elections National
  • Entertainment
    • TV Listings
    • Concerts
    • Rock Hall
    • Cedar Point
    • 100 Hidden Gems
    • 50 Best Patios
  • Traffic
    • Traffic Map
    • Traffic News
    • Gas Prices Cleveland and Akron
  • Best of Class 2025
  • Spotlight 5
  • Cleveland Home Experts
  • Watch Cash Explosion
  • Ohio Lottery Results
  • News 5 User Guide
  • About Us
    • Staff
    • Sales Staff
    • Contact Us
    • News 5 Apps
    • News Literacy
    • Contests
    • Moving Forward
    • Licensing archived video from News 5
    • Advertise
    • WEWS: The first 70 years
    • Support
    • TV Listings
  • Advertise with News 5
  • Sign In
  • Newsletters
  • Sign Out
  • Manage Emails
  • Apps
  • Careers Search
  • Breaking Their Silence
  • Dangerously Understaffed
  • Cleveland Water
  • County Jail
  • Fertility Clinic Failure
  • Diagnosis: Debt
  • Social Insecurity
  • Domestic Violence
1 weather alerts 1 closings/delays
NewsLocal NewsInvestigationsFertility Clinic Failure

Actions

  • Facebook
  • Tweet
  • Email

Letter sent to UH patients about fertility mishap fails to explain why it happened

Prev Next
The latest update to the University Hospital's fertility controversy is a letter the hospital sent to patients. It again offers them free in vitro and storage for their eggs if they want to or even have the ability to go through the process again.
Letter sent to UH patients about fertility mishap still doesn't explain why it happened
By: Amanda VanAllen
Posted
and last updated

University Hospitals has sent a letter to fertility center patients affected by a catastrophic refrigerator malfunction offering free in vitro fertilization packages and storage for their eggs and embryos. 

The letter fails to explain why a temperature fluctuation in a storage tank happened on the first weekend in March. 

In a previous letter, hospital staff said approximately 2,000 eggs and embryos were either damaged or destroyed because of a refrigerator malfunction at the UH Fertility Center Beachwood, Ohio.   

RELATED: Here's everything we know about the University Hospitals fertility storage malfunction

The letter also vaguely walks patients through some of the things they are looking into as a potential cause for the malfunction, including security and alarm systems.

The letter also reveals the hospital purchased new storage tanks and tank alarms from a different vendor.

RELATED: New lawsuit alleges previous failure at University Hospitals Fertility Center

"University Hospital is behaving like an airline that just had a plane crash," said attorney Tom Merriman,  who is representing several UH patients. "The thing that strikes me about this letter is that its phony transparency, its cast in terms of as though they're trying to be transparent with patients who lost their embryos and eggs but, in reality, it doesn't tell you anything. I can’t believe that after a week and a half they have no idea how 2,000 eggs and embryos were destroyed in a liquid nitrogen holding tank."

UH declined to comment until all of their patients receive the letter.

Devastated families and dreams of having children shattered. 
This after 2 thousand eggs and embryos were potentially destroyed because of a refrigerator malfunction at University Hospital. 
The latest update to the controversy is this letter the hospital sent to patients. It *again* offers them free in vitro and storage for their eggs if they want to or even have the ability to go through the process again. 
The letter also *very vaguely* walks patients through some of the things they are looking into as a potential cause like: security and alarm systems. 
They also reveal purchasing new storage tanks and tank alarms from a different vendor. 
An attorney who is representing several clients affected by the mishap is very critical of the letter. 
 
>>TOM MERRIMAN, ATTORNEY 

(33:27)

University Hospital is behaving like an airline that just had a plane crash. The thing that strikes me about this letter is that it’s phony transparency, its cast in terms of as though their trying to be transparent with patients who lost their embryos and eggs but in reality it doesn’t tell you anything. I can’t believe that after a week and a half they have no idea how 2 thousand eggs and embryos were destroyed in a liquid nitrogen holding tank. 
 
LIVE OUT: 
We did give U-H the opportunity to talk about the new developments, but they say they would prefer all of their patients receive the letter before they comment further. 
Copyright 2018 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Sign up for What Happened Now? - a daily email newsletter spotlighting the top news in the Cleveland area each day.

now signed up to receive the What Happened Now?

Click here to manage all Newsletters
Download our streaming app on your favorite device.  Click here for more.

Click here for stories we’ve followed through on and to submit your ideas.

News 5 Investigators Contact Form
Do you have an issue or story that you want News 5 Investigators to look into? Email InvestigatorTips@wews.com or fill out the form below.
  • Northeast Ohio Traffic
  • News
  • Don't Waste Your Money Team
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Life
  • Video
  • Marketplace
  • Don't Waste Your Money
  • Support
  • Sitemap
  • Do Not Sell My Info
  • Privacy Policy
  • Privacy Center
  • Journalism Ethics Guidelines
  • Terms of Use
  • EEO
  • Careers
  • FCC Public Files
  • FCC Application
  • Public File Contact
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Scripps Media Trust Center
  • Closed Captioning Contact
  • News5Cleveland
  • WEWS
Scripps News Group
© 2025 Scripps Media, Inc
Give Light and the People Will Find Their Own Way