Ohio Gov. John Kasich fell into a common trap while campaigning in his home state of Ohio the day before the primary election. He repeated a famous saying without checking it first.
Explaining how he planned to fend off outside interests in his decision making, the Republican presidential candidate invoked the 33rd president, saying, “You know what Truman said -- ‘You want a friend in Washington, buy a dog.’”
It does sound like one of the folksy, farm-charm quips for which Harry S. Truman is known. He’s the leader whose desk displayed the plaque reading, “The buck stops here.”
But did Truman really say that? Or is it a myth that solidified through repetition, like a thousand witticisms wrongly attributed to George Carlin in email chains?
The definitive information comes from the historians at the Harry S. Truman Library and Museum. Sam Rushay, supervisory archivist, told us, “We have never been able to confirm or verify that President Truman ever wrote or said, ‘If you want a friend in Washington, get a dog,’ a quote that is often attributed to him.”
The most often cited source for the non-quote is from a work of fiction. In the play Give ‘em Hell, Harry, written by Samuel Gallu in 1975, Truman’s character says, “You want a friend in life, get a dog!”
Previous investigatorshave found the mistake in a 1987 op-ed in the New York Times, and in a 1989 column by the New York Times’ Maureen Dowd. In both cases, the writers credited the quote to the real Truman, and substituted the word “Washington” for “life.”
History proves that Truman was no fan of dogs. The Presidential Pet Museum’s website includes a page on “President Truman’s Unwanted Dog, Feller,” given to the White House as a gift from a supporter. The president gave the puppy away to his doctor, which didn’t play well in the press.
A reporter asked Truman, “Whatever happened to Feller?”
“To what?” Truman said.
“Feller, the puppy,” the reporter said.
“Oh, he’s around,” Truman answered.
Our ruling
Kasich told an Ohio crowd, “You know what Truman said, ‘You want a friend in Washington, buy a dog.’ ” Though that statement is often attributed to Truman, there’s no evidence Truman ever actually said that.
We rate Kasich’s statement False.
Sources
Website, Snopes.com
Website, Presidential Pet Museum,July 22, 2013
Website, TheBark.com
Website, QuoteInvestigator.com
Email, Sam Rushay, supervisory archivist, Harry S. Truman Library and Museum
Article, “Prospects,” New York Times, June 7, 1987
Article, “Bush’s fierce loyalty raises debate on whether it hinders his judgement,” New York Times, Mar. 10, 1989
