The case for Stefanski: Why you shouldn’t judge the Browns' new coach based on one (bad) game

Posted: 5:02 PM, Jan 12, 2020
Updated: 2020-01-12 17:13:23-05
Kevin Stefanski

CLEVELAND — The Cleveland Browns have wrapped up their search for a new head coach, selecting Vikings offensive coordinator Kevin Stefanski to fill the role. The announcement came Sunday afternoon, less than 24 hours after the Vikings were trounced by the 49ers in the divisional round of the playoffs.

While Stefanski’s offense struggled and looked drained throughout the entire game, they did so against an incredible 49ers defense, one that may very well find itself in the Super Bowl next month. So while it’s easy to look at Saturday’s game and feel panic over the hire, Browns fans should take a deep breath and look at the bigger picture. Let's look at the positives around Stefanski being named the next head coach.

His offensive philosophy
Stefanski has been taught by a man who has been successful in pairing the run and pass beautifully in his offenses‚ Gary Kubiak, whom we could end up seeing here in Cleveland soon. Stefanski has had Kubiak as an offensive advisor through a season that found the team in the playoffs and, before Saturday night, found ways to interchange explosiveness from their running backs and wide receivers.

The 37-year-old has successfully created an offense in Minnesota that flows almost perfectly. Opponents have a difficult time differentiating between a play-action scheme and a hand-off because Stefanski has found a way to make them look identical. Most importantly, Stefanski does something the Browns desperately need—he fits his offense around player strengths rather than trying to fit his players into the offense.

“I think the biggest things a lot of times in those games, this year we relied on plays and not players as much, especially from the offensive side of the ball,” Browns wide receiver Jarvis Landry said in a press conference at the end of the season.

Landry’s comment over the usage of plays over players would be resolved if Stefanski’s offensive philosophy carries over to the Browns.

Well-rounded background
In addition to Stefanski being an esteemed up-and-coming offensive mind, he also has a long history of coaching other positions. Stefanski’s 14 years in Minnesota found him coaching multiple positions. He’s spent time coaching quarterbacks, tight ends and running backs, in addition to his experience as offensive coordinator and head coach assistant.

The Browns new head coach has a defensive background as well, playing defensive back in high school and at Penn from 2000 to 2004, winning Ivy League titles three of those years.

While he lacks head coaching experience, he has years of other coaching experience under his belt.

His ability to help a quarterback in need
Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield had a relatively rough second season compared to his rookie year. Going from breaking Peyton Manning and Russell Wilson’s NFL record for most touchdown passes in a rookie season (27) with just 14 interceptions to struggling to throw 22 touchdowns the following season with 21 interceptions is an unfortunate regression.

Mayfield is the team’s franchise quarterback—something they’ve been looking to find for years. It’s important to develop Mayfield’s potential as early as possible, finding his strengths and playing to them.

Stefanski can do that.

Under Stefanski, Vikings quarterback Kirk Cousins found himself playing better and faster, something Mayfield needs. Cousins was able to get the ball out of his hands quicker and had plays drawn that emphasized his strengths, which led to far fewer interceptions and fewer sacks—a problem Mayfield had to deal with all last season. Cousins finished the regular season with the fourth-best passer rating among the league’s starters (107.4) and threw 26 touchdowns to just six interceptions.

If Stefanski can bring this expertise with him to the Browns, Mayfield’s third season in the league could look like the quarterback Cleveland fell in love with in 2018.

Saturday night should not be a factor
Stefanski has no experience as a head coach, Concerns over inexperience are valid. No one wants to see the Browns repeat last season's actions this year. Let those be the concerns you hold with Stefanski, but don’t use a single game against a great defense to write him off.

Whether he was your first choice or not, he will be the head coach of the Cleveland Browns next season. It’s easy to feel cheated out of an experienced coach or feel like the Browns are repeating the past, but there’s only one way to find out, and that’s to give the man a chance—and wait until next season to see how things go.

RELATED: Kevin Stefanski's three biggest priorities for the Browns

Camryn Justice is a digital content producer at News 5 Cleveland. Follow her on Twitter @camijustice.

Click to see how News 5 is fighting for Northeast Ohioans



  • Indianapolis Colts
  • Philadelphia Eagles
  • Oakland Raiders
  • Washington Redskins
  • Houston Texans
  • Cincinnati Bengals
  • Baltimore Ravens
  • Pittsburgh Steelers


  • Dallas Cowboys
  • New York Giants
  • Jacksonville Jaguars
  • New York Jets
  • Tennessee Titans
  • Cincinnati Bengals
  • Baltimore Ravens
  • Pittsburgh Steelers



WEEK 1 · Thu 08/08 · Browns 30, Redskins 10 (1-0)

WEEK 2 · Sat 08/17 · Browns 21, Colts 18 (2-0)

WEEK 3 · Fri 08/23 · Buccaneers 13, Browns 12 (2-1)

WEEK 4 · Thu 08/29 · Browns 20, Lions 16 (3-1)

Regular Season

WEEK 1 · Sun 09/08 · Titans 43, Browns 13 (0-1)

WEEK 2 · Mon 09/16 · Browns 23, Jets 3 (1-1)

WEEK 3 · Sun 09/22 · Rams 20, Browns 13 (1-2)

WEEK 4 · Sun 09/29 · Browns 40, Ravens 25 (2-2)

WEEK 5 · Mon 10/07 · 49ers 31, Browns 3 (2-3)

WEEK 6 · Sun 10/13 · Seahawks 32, Browns 28 (2-4)

WEEK 7 Bye

WEEK 8 · Sun 10/27 · Patriots 27, Browns 13 (2-5)

WEEK 9 · Sun 11/03 · Broncos 24, Browns 19 (2-6)

WEEK 10 · Sun 11/10 · Browns 19, Bills 16 (3-6)

WEEK 11 · Thu 11/14 · Browns 21, Steelers 7 (4-6)

WEEK 12 · Sun 11/24 · Browns 41, Dolphins 24 (5-6)

WEEK 13 · Sun 12/01 · Steelers 20, Browns 13 (5-7)

WEEK 14 · Sun 12/08 · Browns 27, Bengals 19 (6-7)

WEEK 15 · Sun 12/15 · Cardinals 38, Browns 24 (6-8)

WEEK 16 · Sun 12/22 · Ravens 31, Browns 15 (6-9)

WEEK 17 · Sun 12/29 · Bengals 33, Browns 23 (6-10)