INVESTIGATION: The murder of young Mansfield mother, killed by her abuser, could have been stopped

Posted at 7:48 AM, Dec 22, 2017
and last updated 2019-05-29 14:46:25-04

It was a domestic violence murder with too many unanswered questions. News 5 dug for answers and found a tragedy that could’ve been stopped.


It was a tragic story that unfolded on the streets of Mansfield – a city best known for its historic prison featured in movies like the Shawshank Redemption. 


It is also the city that 22-year-old Kaitlyn Carroll Peak called home. It’s where she worked a 9 to 5 job in a medical office while raising her 7-week-old daughter, Kinsley. 

But on March 8, Kaitlyn’s ex-boyfriend Dakota Steagall, 20, made good on a promise he first made to Kaitlyn more than two years earlier.  Dakota shot Kaitlyn multiple times, left her for dead and kidnapped her daughter – before turning the gun on himself. 


The murder-suicide triggered an AMBER Alert. Kaitlyn and Dakota’s families were left with unanswered questions. The News 5 On Your Side Investigative Unit spent nine months digging into the case.  Here’s how we did it.


Family of murdered mom raises questions about police investigation into tragic AMBER alert case


News 5 first extensively chronicled what led up to the domestic violence murder in May.


But a 30-minute special report by News 5, titled, “Who Killed Kaitlyn?” examines not only what led up to the tragedy, but also the critical missteps by police, prosecutors, sheriff’s deputies and court officials who failed to stop it from happening. 

Exclusive video, audio, photos and interviews obtained by News 5 provide a first-hand glimpse into the tragedy, and our special report pieces together the events with hopes that it will spur positive change. 

News 5’s reporting has already prompted officials to commit to sweeping reform in Richland County. You can read about that here.

On March 9, after shooting Kaitlyn, Dakota led authorities on a chase that ended in Wooster. 

Go inside the SWAT team’s efforts to apprehend him.




This domestic violence murder underscores 5 On Your Side Investigators’ two-year investigation into domestic violence in Ohio, which revealed several critical flaws in Ohio’s domestic violence laws and how women often remain at risk from their abusers. 


INVESTIGATION: How authorities failed to arrest Kaitlyn Carroll Peak’s killer days before her murder


Kaitlyn was stalked, scared and threatened by Dakota for more than two years. Her call for help was among more than 1,000 every year in Richland County, according to data reported by police departments to the Ohio Attorney General’s Office. 


But we found her abuser – like many – went unpunished and without treatment. Read more about that here.

We reviewed more than 200 total misdemeanor domestic violence cases filed in Mansfield Municipal Court in 2016. We found: 

  • 1 in 5 abusers were found guilty
  • Sentencing ranged from 30 to 180 days
  • 60 percent of cases were dismissed

In Richland County, there were a total of 52 felony cases filed in 2016. Among those: 

  • 13 cases received prison time
  • Sentencing ranged from 2.5 years’ probation to 3 years prison
  • 40 percent of cases were dismissed